Irene Riad golden lotus

The Legacy Call · Fifty-Second Edition

The Identity That Wins Is Not Always the Identity That Stewards

Oct 9, 2026 · Irene Riad

Edition Fifty-Two | For CEOs and Founders Building Generational Impact & Wealth

Achievement can carry a person to a level of success that their identity has not yet been prepared to carry.

We are very good at asking leaders what they want to achieve next. Entire industries are organized around the question. What we ask far less often, and what I have come to believe matters more, is who a leader needs to become in order to responsibly carry what they are building.

Because success does not only expand opportunity. It expands responsibility. More people whose livelihoods depend on your judgment. More capital that is not only yours. More influence over decisions you will never personally see. More consequence for what happens after you are no longer the one deciding. And greater responsibility asks for a different level of identity than the one that produced the success in the first place.

Responsibility expands faster than the self that holds it

Robert Kegan's In Over Our Heads makes an argument that is more uncomfortable for accomplished leaders than it first appears. The mental demands of modern life, he argues, have risen faster than the complexity of mind many adults bring to meeting them. The problem is not intelligence or effort. It is a mismatch between what is being asked of a person and the way that person makes meaning (Kegan, 1994). Read through the lens of senior leadership, the implication is plain: a title can change overnight and a balance sheet can double in a year, but the structure of meaning-making inside the person holding them develops on its own, slower schedule.

Ronald Heifetz offers a distinction that sharpens the point. Technical problems can be solved with existing expertise. Adaptive challenges cannot. They require learning, and often a change in the values, beliefs and habits of the people facing them (Heifetz, 1994). A leader who has built a career on solving technical problems brilliantly will, at a certain level, meet a challenge that is adaptive, and the challenge will include the leader. The instinctive response is to apply more of what worked. It is rarely the effective one.

The identity built to perform is not the identity built to hold

Consider what sustained achievement quietly teaches. You become the person who solves it. The person who knows the answer. The person who carries the weight. The person who proves their value through performance. None of these is a character flaw. They are adaptations that were rewarded, repeatedly, until they hardened into a self-concept.

Research on leadership effectiveness suggests that this hardening carries a cost. Kaiser and Overfield (2011) describe how strengths used to excess, and a lopsided reliance on one set of strengths at the expense of its complement, become a recurring source of leadership failure. The leader has not lost the strength. They have lost the ability to put it down.

Jung's concept of the persona gives the psychological texture. The persona, in his account, is the face we present to the world, a compromise between the individual and what society expects of them (Jung, 1966). It is useful, even necessary. The risk he identifies is identification: the person comes to believe they are their persona, and whatever does not fit it is pushed out of awareness. For a leader, the persona of the one who always has the answer is expensive to maintain, and increasingly poorly matched to the work of creating conditions in which other people can think.

A founder I have worked with described the shift he was facing as a move from "I am the person who makes things work" to "I am the person who creates the conditions in which the organization can work without me." Notice that neither statement is about skill. Both are statements about who he is.

The second half asks a different question

Jung observed, in his essay on the stages of life, that we cannot live the afternoon of life according to the programme of life's morning (Jung, 1933). The ambition, the proving, the building of position that rightly dominate the first half do not simply continue into the second. They have to be reinterpreted. James Hollis, writing in this tradition, describes the second half of life as the point at which the provisional personality assembled in response to early demands is no longer adequate to the life actually being lived, and a deeper question presses: what is being asked of me now (Hollis, 2005).

I use "half" loosely. Some founders meet this threshold at forty. Others meet it at sixty. What marks it is not age but the moment the old question, how do I accomplish more, stops being sufficient, and a different one begins to form: how do I become someone who can create, serve and lead at a greater level?

What adversity reveals that achievement conceals

Often the threshold is not crossed by choice. A sale, a loss, a health event, a relationship that does not hold, a failure that cannot be outworked. Janoff-Bulman (1992) argued that serious adversity shatters the fundamental assumptions people carry about themselves and the world: that the world is meaningful, that events are controllable, that the self is worthy. Recovery, in her account, involves rebuilding those assumptions on a different footing. Park (2010), reviewing the meaning-making literature, describes the mechanism: people appraise events against their global beliefs, and when the two cannot be reconciled, the resulting distress drives a process of revising either the meaning of the event or the beliefs themselves.

I want to be careful about what this does and does not claim. It does not claim that loss is good, or that every hardship contains a lesson waiting to be extracted. Some things should be grieved. Some things should be named as wrong. But it does suggest why adversity so often becomes the point at which identity is genuinely reconsidered: it removes the evidence the old identity relied on.

I know this not only from research. In my own life there have been seasons when effort and capability were not enough to restore what I wanted restored, and what I discovered in them was how much of my sense of self had been resting on being the one who could.

For those who hold a faith conviction, this is where the question deepens. It becomes less about what to do now and more about what a season is forming in us. I do not believe every painful event happens because God intended the pain. But I do believe that formation can occur in circumstances we would never have chosen, and that it tends to ask for the same thing the developmental research does: an identity that does not depend on the circumstances it can control.

From achievement to stewardship

Davis, Schoorman and Donaldson (1997), in their stewardship theory of management, contrast the self-serving manager of agency theory with the steward, whose motivations align with the objectives of the organization, who finds intrinsic reward in serving it, and who identifies with its purpose rather than primarily with their own advancement. Peter Block (1993) frames stewardship as holding something in trust on behalf of others, choosing service over self-interest. Erikson (1950) placed a related concern at the center of mature adulthood: generativity, the commitment to establishing and guiding the next generation, which McAdams and de St. Aubin (1992) later showed could be studied through what people do, what they say, and the stories they tell about their lives.

Here is where I want to offer a synthesis of my own, and I offer it as an argument rather than a finding. Stewardship requires an identity that does not need the thing it stewards to confirm it. A leader who needs the organization to prove their worth cannot hold it in trust, because they will, however unintentionally, use it. The organization becomes the instrument through which the leader is reassured. Stewardship, by contrast, becomes available to the leader whose sense of self is anchored in something that does not rise and fall with the next result. This is the capacity I call Identity Coherence: the ability to remain internally integrated as the scale of what you carry expands.

It also reframes the question. Success is not only something you create. It is something you are entrusted with. The question is not only what are you building. It is who is the person being entrusted with what you are building.

Becoming more fully who you were created to be

The next level of leadership is not found by becoming someone else. This is where I think much leadership development quietly goes wrong, by implying that growth means replacing the self that got you here with a more impressive one. Jung's account of individuation points the other way. It is a process of becoming whole, integrating what has been lived, including what has been excluded, rather than substituting a new self for the old one (Jung, 1966). What I call a Person of Legacy™ is not a perfected leader. It is a whole one, someone for whom the strengths, the failures and the seasons that broke something open are all pieces of the same work.

Speaking from my own faith, I would put it this way: who we are is something received before it is something achieved. Many traditions say something similar in their own language, that identity precedes performance, and that we are given purpose before we prove it. If that is true, then the identity built for success was never the whole of you. It was one expression of something deeper, and the next chapter is not asking you to abandon it. It is asking whether the person holding the position has grown to match the position.

The identity that helped you succeed deserves respect. It got you here. But what you are now entrusted with may require a more fully integrated version of you, not a different one.

So the question worth sitting with is this: if what you are building were entrusted to you rather than owned by you, what in your identity would have to change?

Irene Riad

I work with visionary leaders who have outgrown the version of themselves that built their success. I help them become the authors of their next chapter, not just the operators of their current one.

References

Block, P. (1993) Stewardship: Choosing Service Over Self-Interest. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler.

Davis, J.H., Schoorman, F.D. and Donaldson, L. (1997) 'Toward a stewardship theory of management', Academy of Management Review, 22(1), pp. 20-47.

Erikson, E.H. (1950) Childhood and Society. New York: W.W. Norton.

Heifetz, R.A. (1994) Leadership Without Easy Answers. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

Hollis, J. (2005) Finding Meaning in the Second Half of Life: How to Finally, Really Grow Up. New York: Gotham Books.

Janoff-Bulman, R. (1992) Shattered Assumptions: Towards a New Psychology of Trauma. New York: Free Press.

Jung, C.G. (1933) Modern Man in Search of a Soul. Translated by W.S. Dell and C.F. Baynes. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner.

Jung, C.G. (1966) Two Essays on Analytical Psychology, Collected Works, Vol. 7. 2nd edn. Translated by R.F.C. Hull. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Kaiser, R.B. and Overfield, D.V. (2011) 'Strengths, strengths overused, and lopsided leadership', Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 63(2), pp. 89-109.

Kegan, R. (1994) In Over Our Heads: The Mental Demands of Modern Life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

McAdams, D.P. and de St. Aubin, E. (1992) 'A theory of generativity and its assessment through self-report, behavioral acts, and narrative themes in autobiography', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 62(6), pp. 1003-1015.

Park, C.L. (2010) 'Making sense of the meaning literature: An integrative review of meaning making and its effects on adjustment to stressful life events', Psychological Bulletin, 136(2), pp. 257-301.

View all editions

The Legacy Call

Subscribe to my newsletter now

Step into your next level of impact, income, and identity.

Subscribe for exclusive content that challenges, uplifts, and equips you to lead with purpose, power, and prosperity.

No spam. Just genuine insights from my private desk to help you grow and lead with authenticity.

Subscribe on LinkedIn