Irene Riad golden lotus

The Legacy Call · Fifty-Third Edition

We Develop Knowledge Before Identity

Oct 17, 2026 · Irene Riad

Edition Fifty-Three | For CEOs and Founders Building Generational Impact & Wealth

We have become remarkably good at developing intelligent people. We have been far less consistent at developing integrated ones.

For decades, professional and leadership education has followed a formula so familiar that it rarely gets examined. Acquire knowledge. Develop skills. Achieve results. Build a career. It has produced extraordinary expertise, and I have no wish to diminish it. But there is a missing foundation underneath it, and the cost of that absence tends to arrive late, usually at the level of leadership where it is most expensive.

The missing foundation is identity.

Two people can receive the same education, the same opportunities and the same information, and go on to create completely different outcomes. The usual explanations are talent, effort or luck. I would like to propose a less comfortable one: what we know is shaped by who we are.

I will make that case in stages, and I will be explicit about where the evidence is strong, where it is thin, and where I am offering my own synthesis. A claim as large as the one in my title deserves that discipline.

A formula built for knowledge

Consider what the knowledge-first model rewards. It rewards the person who masters content, solves the problem and produces the result, and who does so reliably enough that reliability becomes who they are. Rooke and Torbert (2005), reporting on assessments of managers across organizations, found that the "Expert" and "Achiever" orientations together accounted for roughly two thirds of their sample. These are the identities that formal education and early career success reinforce most directly. In their study of chief executives, the few who reliably led their organizations through real transformation were those whose way of seeing themselves and their situation had matured beyond expertise and achievement.

Two cautions belong here. The sample was largely highly educated managers rather than a random cross-section, and the developmental measure behind it is debated. I cite it as a pattern worth taking seriously, not as settled proof.

Business education has asked this question about itself for a long time. Khurana (2007) traced how American business schools drifted from an aspiration of professional formation, including ethical and character development, toward the transmission of technical, analytical knowledge. Ghoshal (2005) argued that management theories taught without attention to the human beings applying them can shape practice in ways never intended. I raise these not to criticize institutions, many of which teach with real rigor, but because they point at the same gap from inside the system.

An old question, with new pressure behind it

The question is far older than business schools. The Greek ideal of paideia meant the formation of a person, not the accumulation of information (Jaeger, 1939), and education is often traced to the Latin educere, to lead out. Mezirow (1991) built a theory of adult learning around the observation that real change in how people see the world is different in kind from learning more facts. Kegan (1994) argued that the mental demands of modern life have outgrown the complexity of mind many adults bring to them.

What has changed is who is asking. The World Economic Forum's (2025) survey of employers reports that they expect 39 per cent of workers' core skills to change by 2030. Analytical thinking remains the top core skill, as one would expect. But the top five also include resilience, flexibility and agility, leadership and social influence, and motivation and self-awareness. Employers are not asking for less knowledge. They are asking for the person who can carry it.

There is a quiet problem inside that request, though. Carden, Jones and Passmore (2022) reviewed how self-awareness is defined across management education and found no consistent definition, with considerable overlap between self-awareness, self-consciousness and self-knowledge. We have put a capacity at the center of leadership development that we have not yet agreed how to describe, let alone how to develop.

Informational learning and transformational learning

Robert Kegan draws a distinction that clarifies what is missing. Informational learning increases what a person knows. Transformational learning changes the form of knowing itself, the way a person makes meaning of what they know (Kegan, 2000). Most education, including most leadership education, is designed for the first. Its measures of success, such as content mastered, frameworks learned and assessments passed, are measures of information.

The limits of this become visible in a well-documented paradox. Argyris (1991) observed that highly skilled professionals are often very good at single-loop learning, correcting errors within existing assumptions, precisely because they have rarely failed. When their strategies do not work, they tend to become defensive, to screen out criticism and to attribute the problem elsewhere. The more accomplished the person, the less practiced they are at examining the assumptions beneath their own success. Information does not reach that layer. Identity is the layer.

In twenty-five years in talent development, assessment and succession, I have worked with thousands of leaders, much of it coaching leaders who were completing programmes delivered by credible business schools. In my experience, the barrier was rarely the content. The content was usually good, and they absorbed it. What stood in their way was how they responded when the content met pressure, who they became when a decision was uncertain, and what they were quietly protecting.

What we know is shaped by who we are

There is a mechanism behind that observation. Klein's (1998) research on naturalistic decision making describes how experienced decision makers under real conditions rarely compare options analytically. They recognize a situation as a familiar pattern drawn from a repertoire built through experience, and act on it. The implication, which is my inference rather than Klein's claim, is that two people with identical knowledge may literally see different situations, because the patterns each has available were formed by different histories, and the interpretation of those histories is part of identity.

Jung's account of the persona and the shadow points in the same direction. The persona is the face we present, shaped by what the world rewards. The shadow is whatever we have excluded from our self-image in order to maintain it (Jung, 1966). A leader cannot see in a decision what they cannot see in themselves. Competence does not close that gap, because the gap is not one of competence.

Parker Palmer, writing about teaching, put the principle plainly: good teaching cannot be reduced to technique. It comes from the identity and integrity of the teacher (Palmer, 1998). We teach who we are. The same is true of leading. Every senior leader is, whether they intend it or not, an educator of the organization around them, and what they model forms the people they lead more reliably than what they say.

What the recent evidence does and does not show

It would be easy to overstate the case, so let me be exact.

Kragt and Day (2020) followed 80 high-potential senior executives in a corporate leadership programme over five months. They found that leader identity, the extent to which a person sees themselves as a leader, was related to the development of certain leadership competencies, such as challenging the status quo, valuing diversity and creating commitment, but not all of them. In their follow-up analyses, leader identity did not itself predict promotion. This is a single organization and a modest sample, so it is suggestive rather than conclusive. But it points to something worth noticing, and I offer this reading as my own: the systems that decide who advances may reward the visible outputs of competence more reliably than the identity beneath them.

On the school side, Cipriano and colleagues (2023) meta-analysed 424 studies covering more than 575,000 students across 53 countries, and found that universal school-based social and emotional learning programmes were associated with gains in social-emotional skills, school climate, peer relationships and academic achievement. The effects varied considerably with programme content and implementation quality. These are children and skills-based programmes, not executive identity work, so I do not claim they prove my thesis. What they do suggest is that attending to the inner development of learners does not compete with academic learning. It can accompany it.

And here is the fair objection to my own title. Identity and knowledge do not develop in neat sequence. Erikson (1968) described identity as forged in the very acts of learning, trying and committing. I agree. "Before" in my title is a claim about priority and attention, not strict chronology. Identity is the structure that determines how knowledge is used, and so it deserves deliberate attention at the foundation of development, not as an afterthought once a leader is already struggling.

The human system behind the competencies

If this is right, then the future of leadership development cannot focus only on competencies. It has to attend to the human system behind them. A leader needs to understand how they think, how they respond under pressure, what drives their decisions, what values guide their influence and what purpose gives meaning to their contribution. None of these is a skill. All of them determine how every skill is used.

This suggests a different sequence. Not only:

Knowledge → Skills → Performance

but:

Identity → Capacity → Skills → Contribution → Legacy

I offer this as my own synthesis, a working proposition rather than an established model. Identity is the coherence of who a person is and what they serve. Capacity is the ability to hold complexity, uncertainty and pressure without distortion, which Kegan's (1994) work frames as the mismatch between what modern life demands and the complexity of mind many adults bring to it. Skills, placed on that foundation, are applied with more stability and less defensiveness. Contribution is work directed beyond the self. Legacy is what continues beyond one's tenure.

The ordering is not a rejection of knowledge. It is a claim about foundations. An analogy from a different field may help, and I offer it as analogy only. Herman's (1992) influential account of recovery from trauma describes a sequence in which establishing safety and stabilization precedes everything else, because later work built on an unstable base does not hold. Development has an order. Skipping the foundation does not eliminate its cost. It defers it.

The curriculum we skip, adversity teaches

If identity is not developed deliberately, it tends to be developed anyway, usually by circumstance. Mezirow (1991) described perspective transformation as often triggered by a "disorienting dilemma," a crisis that makes the existing way of seeing the world no longer workable. A sale, a loss, a failure that cannot be outworked, a relationship that does not hold. Many leaders receive their identity education from exactly these events, because formal education did not offer it earlier and more gently.

I want to be careful here. This does not mean adversity is good, or that every hardship contains a lesson. Some losses should be grieved and some should be named as wrong. But a leader who arrives at such a moment without any foundation of self-understanding has less to draw on than one who has done that work in advance. We are, in effect, leaving the most important curriculum to chance.

For those who hold a faith conviction, this is where the argument deepens. Many faith traditions hold that a human being is a whole, not a mind with a body attached, and that a person is formed rather than assembled. I hold that who we are is something received before it is something achieved, and that the work of development is less about becoming someone different than about becoming whole. What I call a Person of Legacy™ is not a perfected leader. It is an integrated one, someone for whom the strengths, the failures and the seasons that broke something open are all pieces of the same work.

What this would change

If the argument holds, it carries practical implications, and I offer these as implications to test rather than prescriptions.

For leaders and boards, it suggests asking about identity-level readiness alongside competence when someone is promoted, and asking what the person is protecting, not only what they can do. A promotion that expands responsibility faster than the person's capacity to carry it is a risk that rarely appears on the scorecard.

For those who design leadership development, it suggests building programmes that include transformational as well as informational learning: structured reflection, work with real decisions under pressure, and the support to examine assumptions that skilled people tend to defend. Given the definitional gap Carden and colleagues identified, it also suggests being precise about what a programme means by self-awareness before claiming to build it.

For education leaders more broadly, it suggests asking of every programme a second question beside "what will they know": who will they be able to be, under pressure, with what they know?

From education to stewardship

If every leader is an educator of the people around them, then the question becomes one of stewardship: what have I been entrusted to form, and who must I be to form it well? Kegan and Lahey (2016) studied organizations that make development part of everyday work rather than a separate programme, what they call deliberately developmental organizations, and argued that building cultures in which people can examine their own assumptions and grow is itself a form of leadership. That is a stewardship of people, not only of results.

The question we have been asking education to answer is: What can this person do? It is a necessary question. It is no longer a sufficient one.

The question that matters more is: Who is this person becoming through what they are learning?

The future belongs to leaders who are not only highly skilled. It belongs to leaders who are deeply integrated, and who build the conditions in which others can become so.

So the question worth sitting with is this: of everything you have learned in the last five years, how much changed what you know, and how much changed who you are?

Irene Riad

I work with visionary leaders who have outgrown the version of themselves that built their success. I help them become the authors of their next chapter, not just the operators of their current one.

References

Argyris, C. (1991) 'Teaching smart people how to learn', Harvard Business Review, 69(3), pp. 99-109.

Carden, J., Jones, R.J. and Passmore, J. (2022) 'Defining self-awareness in the context of adult development: A systematic literature review', Journal of Management Education, 46(1), pp. 140-177.

Cipriano, C., Strambler, M.J., Naples, L.H., Ha, C., Kirk, M., Wood, M., Sehgal, K., Zieher, A.K., Eveleigh, A., McCarthy, M., Funaro, M., Ponnock, A., Chow, J.C. and Durlak, J. (2023) 'The state of evidence for social and emotional learning: A contemporary meta-analysis of universal school-based SEL interventions', Child Development, 94(5), pp. 1181-1204.

Erikson, E.H. (1968) Identity: Youth and Crisis. New York: W.W. Norton.

Ghoshal, S. (2005) 'Bad management theories are destroying good management practices', Academy of Management Learning and Education, 4(1), pp. 75-91.

Herman, J.L. (1992) Trauma and Recovery. New York: Basic Books.

Jaeger, W. (1939) Paideia: The Ideals of Greek Culture, Vol. 1. Translated by G. Highet. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

Jung, C.G. (1966) Two Essays on Analytical Psychology, Collected Works, Vol. 7. 2nd edn. Translated by R.F.C. Hull. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Kegan, R. (1994) In Over Our Heads: The Mental Demands of Modern Life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Kegan, R. (2000) 'What "form" transforms? A constructive-developmental approach to transformative learning', in Mezirow, J. and Associates (eds) Learning as Transformation: Critical Perspectives on a Theory in Progress. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, pp. 35-69.

Kegan, R. and Lahey, L.L. (2016) An Everyone Culture: Becoming a Deliberately Developmental Organization. Boston, MA: Harvard Business Review Press.

Khurana, R. (2007) From Higher Aims to Hired Hands: The Social Transformation of American Business Schools and the Unfulfilled Promise of Management as a Profession. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Klein, G. (1998) Sources of Power: How People Make Decisions. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Kragt, D. and Day, D.V. (2020) 'Predicting leadership competency development and promotion among high-potential executives: The role of leader identity', Frontiers in Psychology, 11, article 1816.

Mezirow, J. (1991) Transformative Dimensions of Adult Learning. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Palmer, P.J. (1998) The Courage to Teach: Exploring the Inner Landscape of a Teacher's Life. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Rooke, D. and Torbert, W.R. (2005) 'Seven transformations of leadership', Harvard Business Review, 83(4), pp. 66-76.

World Economic Forum (2025) The Future of Jobs Report 2025. Geneva: World Economic Forum.

View all editions

The Legacy Call

Subscribe to my newsletter now

Step into your next level of impact, income, and identity.

Subscribe for exclusive content that challenges, uplifts, and equips you to lead with purpose, power, and prosperity.

No spam. Just genuine insights from my private desk to help you grow and lead with authenticity.

Subscribe on LinkedIn