The Legacy Call · Fifty-Eighth Edition
The Question Every Leader Eventually Asks
Edition Fifty-Eight | For CEOs and Founders Building Generational Impact & Wealth
There is a question that tends to arrive after the success, not before it.
It rarely comes during a crisis, and it does not come from a coach. It comes on an ordinary afternoon, usually in the gap between two meetings: What in my leadership is actually mine?
Not what is effective. Not what is admired. What is mine, consciously chosen, and what did I simply inherit: a pattern from an old role, an old boss, an old version of me that worked at a smaller scale and never got re-examined.
If you have done a lot of development already, you may have noticed that none of it was designed to answer this. It built your skill, sharpened your judgement and widened your view. This question sits underneath all of that.
How an inherited pattern gets in
In Radical Becoming, I describe how, in early childhood, we watch enough of family, school and society to build a persona, a social self made of whatever earns safety and approval (Riad and Tracy, 2024, pp. 66-68). It is not a lie. It is a tool, and a good one. It carries people a long way.
But the persona does not stop forming in childhood. It keeps taking on material from every room we succeed in. A first manager who rewarded certainty. A board that punished doubt. A family business where loyalty meant never disagreeing in public. Each of these teaches a leader a way to be that works, and a way that works is rarely questioned.
There is research that points at something close to this. A study of 92 leaders in Human Relations examined how they tell the story of becoming a leader. Despite very different careers, their accounts converged on four frames: being, engaging, performing and accepting. The authors argue that these stories do more than describe. They help leaders make their identity coherent over time, and they supply scripts for how to behave (Zheng, Meister and Caza, 2021).
My reading of that, and it is my reading, not the authors’ claim, is this. The story you tell about how you became a leader quietly tells you how to lead. If you have never re-examined the story, you may be following a script that was written for a different chapter.
Why more development does not always reach it
I want to be careful here, because the evidence is more modest than the argument we would like to make.
A study of 80 high-potential executives found that leader identity was related to the development of some, though not all, leadership competencies (Kragt and Day, 2020). It does not say identity explains everything. It does suggest that who a leader understands themselves to be is part of how capability grows, and not a footnote to it.
What I have noticed in twenty-five years of working with leaders is a particular kind of gap. A leader can add competence for decades while the identity doing the leading stays largely untouched. The skills improve. The default way of deciding, relating and holding authority is the pattern that was formed early and rewarded often. Nobody asked whether it was chosen.
None of this means the pattern is wrong. Much of it is probably right. The point is that a pattern you have chosen and a pattern you have inherited can look identical from the outside, and only one of them can be authored.
Where my own question came from
I did not arrive at this in a classroom. I am a third-generation expat. I was born and raised in Saudi Arabia for my first fifteen years, to Egyptian parents, and went to an American school from preschool through ninth grade. Then the UK. Then three years at a Swiss-American boarding school, four years at the American University in Cairo, ten years in the UAE, six more in the UK, and now four years in Albania, learning another language from scratch.
Every one of those moves asked the same thing, long before I had the language for it. What actually belongs to me, and what belongs to the culture, the school or the set of expectations I happen to be standing inside right now?
You do not answer a question like that once. You answer it each time the ground shifts.
For twenty-five years I worked inside organisations in talent development, assessment and succession, across eight industries, with thousands of leaders passing through programmes I helped build. Over that time I saw that the question I had been asking about my own identity was sitting quietly underneath every leader I coached. It was usually the real reason the programme did not hold.
I did not set out to build a framework. I set out to answer that question properly, for myself and for them. The search became doctoral research across four disciplines: psychology, neuroscience, spirituality and entrepreneurial leadership. What came out of it was the MOSAIC Integral Leadership System™ and the capacity I call Executive Authorship.
Two stories, one question
I think it matters that my professional story and my personal story turned out to be the same one.
A small qualitative study of 27 healthcare leaders, following an eighteen-month programme in Ireland, found that as leaders developed, their leader identity shifted from being limited to particular domains to being more integrated across them. Reflecting on experiences from work, family and community supported that shift (Ryan, Hammond and MacCurtain, 2024). The study is small, from one country and one sector, with self-selected participants, so I hold it lightly. But it fits what I see.
Senior leaders often keep their lives in separate rooms: the executive, the parent, the child of someone, the believer, the person who is tired. Each room has its own rules, and the leader behaves differently in each. The question what is actually mine? cannot be answered room by room. It needs the whole person in the same conversation.
That is what I mean when I say the years, the roles, the industries and the moves are not scattered background. They are the architecture this work is built to examine.
A way to begin
Take one pattern in your leadership that you rely on. How you handle disagreement, how you hold authority, how you respond to being doubted. Then ask three things:
- Where did I learn this? Name the role, the person or the season.
- What was it protecting then? It almost certainly protected something real.
- Would I choose it today, knowing what I now know? Not whether it works, but whether it is yours.
You do not need to change the pattern to answer. Often the first change is only that you know it is a choice.
What this is for
I do not think success should cost you everything else. I think the leaders who build the most enduring things are the ones willing to become the kind of person who can hold what they are building.
That is not perfection. It is wholeness. The good, the difficult and the parts you would rather not show are all pieces of the same mosaic, and none of them has to be hidden for you to lead well. I also hold, from my faith, that who you are was never defined by any single role or result. That conviction does something practical: it makes it safer to look at what you inherited.
Watch the story behind the work
I tell this story in full in the video at the top of this page, including where MOSAIC and the Executive Authorship Journey™ come from.
So the question worth sitting with is this: what has been running your decisions for the last ten years, something you consciously chose, or something inherited so long ago that you stopped noticing it was ever a choice?
Irene Riad
I work with visionary leaders who have outgrown the version of themselves that built their success. I help them become the authors of their next chapter, not just the operators of their current one.
References
Kragt, D. and Day, D.V. (2020) ‘Predicting leadership competency development and promotion among high-potential executives: The role of leader identity’, Frontiers in Psychology, 11, article 1816.
Riad, I. and Tracy, B. (2024) Radical Becoming: The Superpower of Success. Bloomington, IN: Balboa Press.
Ryan, N.F., Hammond, M. and MacCurtain, S. (2024) ‘A qualitative study unpacking the leader identity development process taking a multi-domain approach’, Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 45(4), pp. 602-618.
Zheng, W., Meister, A. and Caza, B.B. (2021) ‘The stories that make us: Leaders’ origin stories and temporal identity work’, Human Relations, 74(8), pp. 1178-1210.
Take this further
Free · 2-page reflection
What Is Actually Mine?
The six ideas from this edition and a guided reflection for your weekend.
Get free accessAlready have an account? Log in to add it
The Executive Brief
Shaping Authorship Under Pressure
See where your own architecture stands today.
Get the BriefThe Legacy Call
Subscribe to my newsletter now
Step into your next level of impact, income, and identity.
Subscribe for exclusive content that challenges, uplifts, and equips you to lead with purpose, power, and prosperity.
No spam. Just genuine insights from my private desk to help you grow and lead with authenticity.
Subscribe on LinkedIn